I broke up with my boyfriend two days before Christmas. I didn’t really want to. I had really liked this guy and, hell, who really wants to break up with their boyfriend—no matter the circumstances—two days before Christmas? But I did, and it sucked. I knew I had made the right decision, but it’s hard to let go of someone even if they’ve done you wrong. And when it’s over, you can’t help but second guess yourself. Did I make the right choice? Did I do something wrong? Had I overreacted to the situation and made it out to be worse than it was?
The answer to all of these questions is, of course, no. But telling myself that only made me feel marginally better. Come Christmas morning, I was still feeling down and was hardly in the mood to celebrate.
Luckily, I had bought my mother two seasons of The Golden Girls for Christmas. If you know me, you know how much I adore this show. Not only do I own all seven seasons on DVD and, as my roommate can attest, watch them repeatedly, but I often quote or reference the show in casual conversation.
While eating cheesecake: “Did you know Bea Arthur hated cheesecake even though her character, Dorothy, is shown eating it repeatedly on the show?”
While walking down the “personal items” aisle of a drugstore: “There’s a great scene in The Golden Girls when Blanche, Rose, and Dorothy are preparing for a romantic weekend with their respective boyfriends and decide to buy some condoms, but when they go to checkout, the cashier orders a price check on all three boxes over the loudspeaker.”
While battling the flu and/or drinking a hot toddy: “In one episode of The Golden Girls, the three women come down with a case of the flu and get mad at Rose for being in a cheery mood after she makes a hot toddy to make herself feel better. Rose, tired of her roommates’ grumpiness, loses it and yells, ‘Do you know how many of these stinking hot toddies I’ve had to make to keep a smile on my face!’”
I’ve watched this show since I was 14. I’ve seen every episode at least three times (many of them more than that). My senior year of college, while I was writing my thesis, I usually watched the show while I worked. The show had become so familiar that I often forgot I was working.
So this Christmas, to help me get over my breakup, I decided to turn to my old friends, Blanche, Rose, Dorothy, and Sophia. I put in season 1, disc 1, and lay down on the couch, ready to be entertained.
In the first episode—one I’ve seen at least five times—Blanche gets engaged to a man named Harry after she’s known him for only a week. Deciding she’d rather marry him—even if it seems impulsive—than lose him, she accepts his proposal and they plan the wedding for the following week. Dorothy and Rose think she’s making the wrong decision—after all, she barely knows the guy—but decide they’d rather let their friend be happy than interfere on a hunch. Everything is set for the wedding, but just minutes before the ceremony, a cop arrives at the house (I guess, due to the short notice, Blanche just decided to get married in her living room) to inform the bride-to-be that her fiance has been arrested for bigamy and has six wives.
Blanche, of course, is devastated, but with the help of her friends (and a slice or two of cheesecake), she picks up and moves on by the next episode. She’s over it. Harry never comes back into the picture.
As I watched this episode, I began to think about how many Golden Girls episodes carry a similar arc. Over and over gain, these women get their hearts broken and dreams dashed by a slew of creepy, dishonest bastards. But every time, without fail, they get over it, and before you can say “Back in St. Olaf,” they’re back in the game with some new beau.
Of course, the girls also know how to take matters into their own hands. In another episode from season 1, Dorothy starts sleeping with Glenn, the gym teacher at the school where she works as a substitute. After one of their hotel-room trysts (why she never bothered to ask him why they had to meet in a hotel room is beyond me), Glenn tells Dorothy he is married. Dorothy is, of course, shocked and upset and walks out of the room saying she doesn’t want to see him anymore. He calls her several times, pleading with her, telling her he loves her and his marriage is in shambles anyway. After a while, she relents and begins to see him again, telling herself that he loves her and makes her happy so it doesn’t matter.
But, of course, it does, and eventually, after Dorothy realizes that Glenn isn’t going to leave his wife for her, she leaves him again. She’s sad, and admits it, but decides that her self-respect is more important to her than this man.
But that’s not the last we see of Glenn. In a later season, he calls Dorothy to tell her that he’s left his wife and he’s still in love with her. Dorothy is understandably, ecstatic. Her dream has come true! The man she loves left his wife and wants to be with her! How romantic! They start to see each other again (this time hosting their rendezvous at his bachelor pad instead of a motel), and things seem to be going great. That is, until one day when Glenn receives a phone call from his ex wife while Dorothy is visiting. He answers and asks, impatiently, what she wants. “Sure, I’m alone,” he says, much to the surprise of Dorothy who is sitting in the same room. When Glenn hangs up, Dorothy turns to him. “Alone?” she asks, the pain apparent in her tone. Glenn makes up some excuse about not wanting to complicate things or upset his already angry ex, but Dorothy isn’t having it. She is no longer his mistress and refuses to be treated like one, so she leaves him, again, just as disappointed as before, but this time disappointed with herself for not knowing better.
This episode in particular resonated with me. The situation was not the same, by any means (I will not go into the details of my breakup here, but I will say, for the record, that I was NOT sleeping with a married man or, for that matter, a divorced one), but the feelings of disappointment were incredibly familiar. Like Dorothy, I had had high hopes for my relationship and had developed excuses for my boyfriend’s behavior. I had told myself that I could handle the situation. Everything would be fine.
And, like Dorothy, I eventually realized that I was compromising myself. I was allowing myself to be miserable so I wouldn’t have to confront the situation head on. I told myself I was overreacting. I told myself I was being insecure. I told myself I needed to be patient with him. But the more I told myself these things, the more I realized none of them were true. So I ended it, just as Dorothy had done.
As I considered the parallels, I began to feel better. Some people listen to sappy songs (“Goodbye My Lover,” anyone?) to get over a breakup. I watch The Golden Girls. There’s a certain comfort in watching four older women (three widows and a divorcee), go through the same painful experiences you do and get through them. It’s like having four different grandmothers—all with their own characteristic brand of wit—sit you down over a piece of cake and a cup of hot tea and tell you stories from their own lives so you don’t feel like you’re going through these things alone.
So, am I sad? Yes, I’m still sad, but I’m also proud of what I did, and I know that, if they were here, Blanche, Rose, Dorothy, and Sophia would be proud of me too. Plus, if three fifty-somethings and one eighty-year-old can still get lucky, I’m fairly confident that I’ll be back in the game soon enough.

